reality-tv-online.com - 3/18/2009
—
It’s country week on American Idol. This season the contestants were mentored by Randy Travis as they performed songs made famous at the Grand Ole Opry. Here’s what I thought about the show tonight.
Michael Sarver. Michael is from Texas so you would think that this genre would be right up his ...
Carrie Underwood and Randy Travis Duet - “I Told You So” —
Idol Stalker
American Idol winner (and Grand Ole Opry inductee), Carrie Underwood , returned during last night’s results show where she performed a duet with country music legend, Randy Travis . They sang “I Told You So” which is from Randy’s recently released album Told You So – The Ultimate Hits ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 Do Country Week —
Idol Stalker
Last night, the Top 11 contestants performed on American Idol . They did country songs and, for the most part, it went a lot better than I was expecting. I have to say, however, that the weird new entrance with the voice announcing the judges and them walking out onto the stage is ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Matt Giraud “So Small” —
Idol Stalker
Matt Giraud picked “ So Small” by Carrie Underwood and accompanied himself on the piano. I did feel that he was so busy playing the piano that I think he neglected his vocals. It definitely wasn’t his best performance, in my opinion, but I did like the arrangement.
Kara said ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Megan Joy —
Idol Stalker
Megan Joy put her personality on Patsy Kline’ s song “ Walking After Midnight” and I wasn’t sure I was going to like it but I did (I didn’t love it, though). I am a little annoyed by her pronunciation but I respect her as an artist.
Randy said that he was quite impressed, it was a ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Megan Joy “Walking After Midnight” —
Idol Stalker
Megan Joy put her personality on Patsy Kline’ s song “ Walking After Midnight” and I wasn’t sure I was going to like it but I did (I didn’t love it, though). I am a little annoyed by her pronunciation but I respect her as an artist. Randy said that he was quite impressed, it was a ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Anoop Desai —
Idol Stalker
Anoop Desai tackled the Willie Nelson classic “ You Were Always On My Mind” and I was really happy to see Anoop taking song choice seriously and showing off the vocals that got him past the auditions.
Paula said that she was proud of him for picking a song that fit him so well. ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Danny Gokey —
Idol Stalker
Danny Gokey had a hard time mastering the lyrics to Carrie Underwood’ s breakout hit “ Jesus Take the Wheel” and, while it started a little rough for me, he really sounded great during the chorus. I loved his white jacket too!
Kara said that the first part of the performance wasn’t ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Danny Gokey “Jesus Take the Wheel” —
Idol Stalker
Danny Gokey had a hard time mastering the lyrics to Carrie Underwood’ s breakout hit “ Jesus Take the Wheel” and, while it started a little rough for me, he really sounded great during the chorus. I loved his white jacket too!
Kara said that the first part of the performance wasn’t ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Alexis Grace —
Idol Stalker
Alexis Grace chose “ Jolene” by Dolly Parton which didn’t surprise me too much but I didn’t like the arrangement or the performance. It was okay but it could have been a lot better.
Randy said there were a lot of pitch problems and the arrangement didn’t quite work. Kara ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Scott MacIntyre “Wild Angels” —
Idol Stalker
Scott MacIntyre sang “ Wild Angels” by Martina McBride and the audience really got into it toward the end but I found it a little boring. I feel like he also slides in and out of notes. I like Scott but I don’t have the same level of excitement for him as I think a lot of other ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Scott MacIntyre —
Idol Stalker
Scott MacIntyre sang “ Wild Angels” by Martina McBride and the audience really got into it toward the end but I found it a little boring. I feel like he also slides in and out of notes. I like Scott but I don’t have the same level of excitement for him as I think
Paula said it was ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Adam Lambert —
Idol Stalker
Adam Lambert sang a really altered version of Johnny Cash’ s famous song “Ring of Fire” and I’ve been really hard on Adam every week but this week he TOTALLY won me over. WOW! I couldn’t believe it was even the same song!
Kara said it was all a little strange but she enjoyed the ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Lil Rounds —
Idol Stalker
Lil Rounds chose to sing Martina McBride’ s big hit “ Independence Day” and, while I absolutely love Lil, I wasn’t a huge fan of this performance. The crowd seemed to enjoy it but I wouldn’t have picked that song for her.
Randy said it was an interesting and ambitious song choice but it ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Lil Rounds “Independence Day” —
Idol Stalker
Lil Rounds chose to sing Martina McBride’ s big hit “ Independence Day” and, while I absolutely love Lil, I wasn’t a huge fan of this performance. The crowd seemed to enjoy it but I wouldn’t have picked that song for her.
Randy said it was an interesting and ambitious song choice ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Kris Allen —
Idol Stalker
Kris Allen sang another of my favorite songs “ To Make You Feel My Love” (can you tell I love Garth Brooks ?) and I was speechless and riveted by him for the first time. That could be a single on the radio right now! I LOVED it!!!!!!!!
Paula said she was pleasantly surprised and ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Allison Iraheta —
Idol Stalker
Allison Iraheta sang Patti Loveless’ song “Blame it on Your Heart” and, again, I was totally blown away by the maturity of her voice and stage presence. I guess it was a fun choice for her and I think it suited her feisty personality.
Kara said that Allison made that song her own and ...
American Idol 8 Top 11 – Michael Sarver —
Idol Stalker
Michael Sarver sang one of my favorite country songs Garth Brooks iconic classic “Ain’t Goin’ Down Till The Sun Comes Up” and, while I liked it, I think he should have picked a song that allowed him to show off his vocals a little more. He flubbed the lyrics a bit in the middle but it ...